This study is a subanalysis of baseline data from a randomized control trial that evaluated the impact of an interprofessional shared decision making aid on decisional conflict, diabetes distress, patient assessment of. The north american nursing diagnosis association 1992 included decisional conflict in its taxonomy of problems. For all subscales higher scores indicate greater decisional conflict. The decisional conflict scale dcs measures 5 dimensions of decision making feeling. Decisional conflict is a central determinant of decision making, particularly in the context of uncertainty. This study aims to produce the first mandarin version of the sfdcs and test its validity and reliability in mainland china. Decisionmaking patterns, conflict sytles, and selfesteem. Decisional conflict is associated with decision quality and may affect decision outcomes. It is also one of the most frequently reported outcomes in studies on decision support interventions. To describe the purposes and basic properties of the decision conflict scale dcs, including number of items and scales and psychometric properties. Decisional conflict between treatment options among endstage.
Moving from the individual to the dyad level find, read and. Parental decision making involvement and decisional. Comparison of versions of the decisional conflict scale dcs table. Decisional conflict is defined as personal uncertainty about which option to choose. Measuring staff nurse decisional involvement the decisional involvement scale donna sullivan havens, phd, rn joseph vasey, phd. Prevalence of clinically significant decisional conflict. Traditional decisional conflict scale dcs statement.
User manual decisional conflict scale patient decision aids. I want to take my surgery but it will also take 3 months for recovery. The scale discriminates between those who make or delay decisions, is correlated with knowledge. Decisional conflict is an intrapersonal psychological construct that is felt by individuals when facing decisions that involve risk, loss, regret or challenges to personal life values. Efforts to understand womens decisional conflict experiences following diagnosis has the potential to yield important insights about their emotional responses i. Heres a good sample of nursing care plan for decisional conflict. The decisional conflict scale is a validated research measurement instrument that assesses modifiable decisional conflict factors, such as patient knowledge, values, and support.
The original, 16item version of the decisional conflict scale dcs is widely used for decision aid evaluations 1214. Decisional conflict is a significant and important barrier in endoflife care planning, and it is often encountered in health professionals discussions with patients and their families. The decisional conflict scale was administered before the intervention and immediately after. There was no difference between immediate postvisit and 30 day dcs p. In pediatrics, research shows that many parents are insufficiently involved in decisions about their childs health. However, it is more difficult to respond to than questions in those with limited reading and response skills. This scale was developed to determine whether a client is experiencing decisional conflict or uncertainty and to identify some of the key determinants contributing to decisional conflict such as feeling uninformed, unclear about values, unsupported in decision making oconnor, 1995 x oconnor, 1995 oconnor, a. Decisional conflict is a state of uncertainty about the best treatment option among competing alternatives and is common among adult patients who are inadequately involved in the health decision making process. Clarify and prioritize individual goals, noting where the subject of the conflict falls on this scale. Methods a retrospective, crosssectional, webbased survey via an online questionnaire available in three languages with specific items concerning cancer, fertility, fertility preservation and the validated decisional conflict scale targeted at current or former female cancer patients aged 1845 years, with cancer types or treatment. Better understanding of the reasons behind high decisional conflict can help surgeons support highquality decisions and lead to more satisfactory outcomes and less decisional regret. The original, 16item version of the decisional conflict scale dcs is widely used for decision aid evaluations 12 14.
Development and validation of the japanese version of the. The magnitude of the differences in parent knowledge, decisional conflict, and parent involvement observed in this trial is similar to prior trials of encounterlevel decision aids. In this paper, janis and mann present a then new theory of how people process information related to decisionmaking. Decisional conflict scale evaluation measures patient decision. A total of 112 dyads of physicians and patients were included in the analysis. Decisional conflict nursing care plan assessment subjective. The decisional conflict scale dcs is a selfadministered questionnaire that was originally designed to assess decisional conflict in patients. Pdf validity of a low literacy version of the decisional. Decisional conflict was dichotomized into no decisional conflict score0 and any decisional conflict score0. Adolescent and parent perspectives on medical decisionmaking for chronic illness psychometric testing was performed on the sure decisional conflict scale and the instrument was found to be acceptable, feasible and easy to administer.
Request pdf on jul 3, 2012, france legare and others published the decisional conflict scale. Pdf parental decision making involvement and decisional. Addressing decisional conflict about fertility preservation. The study objective was to evaluate the psychometric properties of a decisional conflict scale dcs that elicits. Over the past two decades, it has been widely used as a measurement tool to assess the effect of decision support interventions, especially patient decision aids pdas 2,3,4. Crosscultural adaptation and psychometric assessment of the. When a serious or term nor 3, is a questionnaire designed for use in studies of inal.
Adolescents had higher decisional conflict scores than parents 15. Are you sure assessing patient decisional conflict with a 4. A decisional conflict model in 1977, irving janis and leon mann proposed a descriptive model of the decision making process, in which they advanced the idea that the need to make a decision involves a conflict which en genders a certain degree of stress, the excess or absence of which. Webster university of british columbia, vancouver, british columbia, canada thirtyone clients completed a sixweek program using gestalt twochair dialogue to work on intrapsychic conflict related to the making of a. This study is a subanalysis of baseline data from a randomized control. Resolving decisional conflict by gestalt twochair dialogue. Decisional conflict in patients and their physicians.
Endoflife decisionmaking, decisional conflict, and enhanced information. Crosscultural adaptation and psychometric assessment of. We used the spanish version of the decisional conflict scale dcs 38, 39 that evaluates the level of patients uncertainty when they are confronted to a medical decision. Relationship among diabetes distress, decisional conflict. Validity of a low literacy version of the decisional conflict scale. Item response theory analysis and properties of decisional. Janis and leon mann, in american scientist 64, novdec 1976 read november 2010.
We investigated potential characteristics of patients with decisional conflict using bivariate and multivariable logistic regression. Structural equation modeling was used to measure the parameters of the actorpartner interdependence model. Traditional decisional conflict scale dcs statement format. Apr 17, 20 the decisional conflict scale dcs is a 16item, selfadministered questionnaire consisting of 5 subscales developed to assess patients decisional conflict. These constructs can be measured using the diabetes distress scale dds, decisional conflict scale dcs, shortform survey 12 sf12, and patient assessment of chronic illness care pacic scale, which have been used across the population with diabetes 9,12,18,21,25. Identify strengths and presence of positive coping skills e. Impact of educational and patient decision aids on. Effect of a decision aid in parents of children with minor. This study aimed to develop the japanese version of the dcs and to clarify the influence of the information provided by pharmacists on decisional conflict among patients with cancer. Validation of the decisional conflict scale for evaluating. Validity of a low literacy version of the decisional conflict.
Decisional conflict scale 16 item statement format. Validity of a low literacy version of the decisional. In the health sciences literature, the decisional conflict scale is widely used to measure decisional conflict, yet limited research has described the psychometric properties of the decisional conflict scale subscales and of the low literacy version of the scale. The decisional conflict scale dcs was developed in 1995 to measure decisional conflict and related factors, enable the tailoring of decision support interventions desis to patients decisional needs, and evaluate the effectiveness of desis. The statement format of the decisional conflict scale sfdcs is designed and widely used to assess patients state of uncertainty during health related decision making. We sought to measure decisional conflict in surrogates of critically ill patients and to examine whether prior. Coping with decisional conflict jenny shireys graduate. Decisional conflict scale for mandarin version cui lu1, wei mu2, yinghui jin3, yuexian shi4,geli5, yan li6, fei han7 and tian xia8 abstract background. Oct 26, 2019 after independently choosing categories of conditions to learn for the adolescent, participants completed the validated decisional conflict scale and a survey assessing factors influencing their respective choices. The decisional conflict scale has five 0100 subscales. Pdf decisional conflict in patients and their physicians.
Decision analysis and the video plus leaflet interacted interaction coefficient 12. Descriptive statistics and forward stepwise linear regression analyses were used. Nov 21, 2019 the statement format of the decisional conflict scale sfdcs is designed and widely used to assess patients state of uncertainty during health related decision making. The decisional conflict scale dcs is a selfadministered questionnaire. The final sample consisted of 342 women who completed all 16 items of the decisional conflict scale. The decisional conflict scale dcs is a 16item, selfadministered questionnaire consisting of 5 subscales developed to assess patients decisional conflict. Decisional conflict in doctor acr meeting abstracts. Among a crosssectional sample of patients with esrd n464 surveyed in 2014 and 2015, we assessed decisional conflict through a validated 10item questionnaire.
The decisional conflict scale dcs measures personal perceptions of. The purpose of this secondary data analysis was therefore to examine properties of the original. Decisional conflict can be measured in the surgical setting using the 16item validated patientreported decisional conflict scale dcs. Dc about fertility preservation was measured with the validated decisional conflict scale dcs. The study objective was to evaluate the psychometric properties of a decisional conflict scale. As yet no mandarin version of the sfdcs has been produced. In the health sciences literature, the decisional conflict scale is widely used to measure decisional conflict, yet limited research has described the psychometric properties of the decisional. Decisional conflict is when a person is uncertain about which course of action to choose when the choices have involve risk, challenge, or negative or disadvantage to personal life values.
While the dcs uses item statements and a 5point agreement scale. We aimed to identify the prevalence and characteristics associated with decisional conflict between treatment options in esrd patients presenting for transplant evaluation. Conflict resolution among rn staff on unit figure 1. Crosssectional study among 186 patients in dutch specialist mental health care using the decisional conflict scale, which measures five dimensions of decisional conflict.
The scale has five subscales, including uncertainty 3 items, informed 3 items, values clarity 3. In this study, psychometric properties of the decisional conflict scale, which was. Nov 05, 2015 this critical synthesis package contains. The scale has since been adapted to and tested among health professionals, since decisional conflict as seen by doctors, nurses and other healthcare providers has proven useful in evaluating the. To study the effect of shared decisionmaking sdm on decisional conflict dc scores immediately after consultation and to assess the decisional regret dr scores in the first 3 months. Mean postvisit decisional conflict scale score dcs 1 was 18. This study is a subanalysis of baseline data from a randomized control trial that evaluated the impact of an. Parents who were engaged in ct decisionmaking using the decision aid. Decision aids reduced decisional conflict in patients with. Decisional conflict among adolescents and parents making. Objectives unresolved clinically significant decisional conflict csdc in patients following a consultation with health professionals is often the result of inadequate patient involvement in decisionmaking and may result in poor outcomes. Decisional conflict definition of decisional conflict by.
Are you sure assessing patient decisional conflict with. Decisional conflict legal definition of decisional conflict. In their research, they found that peoples information preferences are not the same in all. My family depends on me and that 3 months of absense in my work would cause too much trouble, as verbalized by the patient. We explored decisional conflict as measured with the 16item decisional conflict scale dcs and how it varies across clinical situations, decision types, and exposure to decision. Quantitative data analysis consisted of descriptive and correlational. Validation of the decisional conflict scale for evaluating advance. After a clinical encounter, modifiable deficits and personal uncertainty were measured in physicians and patients using the decisional conflict scale. Moving from the individual to the dyad level, abstract decisional conflict is a central determinant of decision making, particularly in the context of uncertainty. Oconnor and colleagues offer an alternative, 10item version of the dcs, appropriate for individuals. The 16item dcs is a measure of the level of eol decisional conflict often experienced when patients medical care decisionmaking involves risktaking, uncertain outcomes, or a tradeoff of values in a choice 9, 16. Oconnor and colleagues offer an alternative, 10item version of the dcs, appropriate for individuals with low literacy skills dcsll. A feasibility randomised controlled trial of the decide.
Decisional conflict scale findings among patients and. The scales used were decisional conflict and regret scales, satisfaction with genetic counselling scale, and health. Definition of decisional conflict decisional conflict, described by janis and mann 1977, is the simultaneous opposing tendencies within the individual to accept and reject a given course of action p. We sought to identify the prevalence of csdc in studies on decisionmaking in primary care and to explore its risk factors. Psychometric testing of the decisional conflict scale. Annals of the american thoracic society ats journals. Decisional conflict refers to an individuals perception of uncertainty about the course of action to take when the choices involve risk, loss, regret, or a challenge to personal life values. The applicability of the decisional unlv libraries. The most wellknown measure is the decisional conflict scale dcs. If the score or subscore is reported as a percentage or on a 0100 scale no conversion is required. An evidencebased approach to managing womens decisional. The decisional conflict scale dcs was first developed in 1995 for measuring perceptions of uncertainties in the study of patients personal healthcare decisionmaking process. Little is known about the measurement of decisional conflict, and existing measures are not suitable for all contexts.
1316 190 199 1049 398 1185 691 141 1360 1026 1095 619 1601 225 511 76 31 119 1303 1290 963 935 1104 1546 1411 633 126 7 1047 934 1103 23 1024 959 436 1458 445 716 1161